Just the opinion of a simple fan of the universe … The video was shot on the 17th, 19th was published … Well, in the coming days an expanded opinion will be released, but for now you can write your opinions in comments … including the questions “What No.*!% you carry. This is the failure of the year. ". I will try to give a logical explanation to most blunders. PySy: In the video there is Strong Langvage. 18+ and all things ..
The best comments
This is just the most failure of the saga and there are a number of reasons for this. Music and visual component of questions does not raise. But we did not just come to the picture gallery to look at the angles. First of all, one of the disadvantages is the drawback of dialogs, the whole film we see battles and running around. But where are the dialogs about the strength and its roles, which were famous for the previous parts. The next characters are completely unsolved from this drawback, we do not see their experiences, their thoughts, we see on the screen only the heavy breathing of the final. The third drawback is the absence of logic in battles. Especially in the final one, I will not disclose its content so that there are no spoilers in my comment, but damn, as possible, years of training, knowledge of anger, rage and nourishment from it, forces against it, under-deposited self-taught. And where the hell is his real villain, where the power of Darth Vader, who crushed his subordinates and kept in fear the whole galaxy, where the master of fighting on light swords like Dart say, who coped with two Jedi at once. In the same episode, the villain is similar to a schoolboy who, in the case of a merged, cries the keyboard and freaks out, beats against the walls of the head. Not some charisma in him is not, he does not cause a sense of fear and horror, he is simply-no one. He is even put at the same level with some general, whom Vader strangled one after another. I have nothing more to say. I left the session with a feeling of bitterness and annoyance for the previous units, which were real stellar wars in which the soul was invested, and not just created an empty cover, a picture as in this case.
And and even forgot to mention that there was no tension in the battle that the battles of all parts of the saga were saturated
Dialogues, yes, Padme’s Padme’s love conversations with Enakin, this is not enough, I agree. The most interesting points. And the main thing is that everyone always sits, or just stand, the scenes are standed the same, always one face and nape of the character and then another. This simplicity reveals the entire directorial genius of Lucas, but he does not even strain, sits and drinks coffee. But what the logic used to be in battles, eh, and this long battle in the third part has never hung up. And then, as the upholstered, for example, does not react to the spinning swords of Grivus, shows not that in front of him is a 3D doll, which he does not even see, but a real endurance of Jedi! And what soul was invested in these three parts, so many characters So many figures can be sold! was diverse, and most importantly not flat, memorable. So, yes, I agree, the new part of the shit, but before, it used to be good ..
The video is not bad, really not bad. But it is worth speaking more slowly and clearer, at times it cuts ears, for example, at 3:46, when you say, about "sticks". Some words are difficult to make out. And do not raise your voice in the words “fucking” and “in the ass”, if the words themselves do not cause problems, then the presentation is too accentuated to them, or something, is too highlighted against the general background, although it is possible that you wanted.
Thanks for the advice. The Visit Website first video with a new microphone, but after the old I am not used to it yet … Well, I am training slowly ..
Well, well … I hope I can make the second part of the video with the arguments “why the plot is not SOS №T?". Perhaps you will change your point of view … at least to neutral.
As I remember now.
10 years ago, after the release of the revenge, Sitov Lucas said that the saga was over. Then we also discussed in the yard-what could be a potential 7th episode and subsequent. As a result, they agreed that it was possible to repeat the main trilogy (4-5-6 episodes), they say the children of the khan, the students of the hatch and so on and the TP will have the main roles, the empire is split, but there may be few events themselves or they, the events will no longer be in the novelty.
Then the gaze fell on Kotor. And immediately the hope of the return of stellar wars to the screens lurked. Judge for yourself. In fact, the main events unfolded in the days of the old republic – the Wars of the Sito and Jedi, the Mandolorian wars and TD, etc. – there are no strict frames from the main saga, a clean sheet. And what do we see? Announcement of the 7th episode. Almost the entire universe is recognized by non -canon. For what?
And now the film comes out. I, like a fan of the ZV, went to the premiere without expecting absolutely nothing – just interest. But I was disappointed. Rude copy of the 4th episode. Yes, the same hidden threat is conceptually similar to a new hope, but it was not so noticeable. Yes, the plot holes were present, but again – white threads did not stick out everywhere. In the 7th episode absolutely did not like everything. Many say that shooting is good. Yes, this is so, but in the yard 2015 and a beautiful wrapper is difficult to surprise. And what remains under the wrapper? Empty wooden characters, a cheap trick with the involvement of an old guard in the form of an exaltation of lovers of the original trilogy, an absolutely holey plot. Speaking in a little detail, then:
-The characters are not remembered. The main characters are ridiculous – the scriptwriters themselves do not seem to understand who the emphasis on. Finn, trained soldier from childhood, do not show soldier’s resistance. Rey throughout the film runs with the face of Aka Sylvester Stallone in any action movie with his participation. The elite pilot of the rebels (I do not remember the name) is allotted too little time. A villain … You can talk a lot about the villain, but Adam Driver does not stupidly fit this role, and his character, like everyone else, is written on his knee, but here the contrast is very well noticeable and we get it incomprehensible what is not clear what.
-Plot. He spins, turns and does not find supports. Everything is repeated, even moments and scenes cause deja vuju level 80. The illogicality also captured the plot, which is sucked out of the finger of the “Starkiller” work (well, there is generally a failure in originality or this is a tribute to the TFU protagonist?)
-Fight on light swords. Here without comments.
Summing up, I want to say.
Everything is bad.
Well, how to say. The first films are really good from a directed point of view, and since Lucas was not particularly known, he really had to try. Moments, but logic is lame, but if you find fault, then the same lord of the rings cannot be watched, like a bunch of other works, here is the question in the number of these logical holes. But the prequels … Well, I can’t watch them physically, they are not only removed disgusting, well, it’s hard to shoot when you sit on the ass all the time, drink coffee and look at two monitors. After all, otherwise you have to get up, so the monitors are moving too! But the plot, characters, logic … oh. How painful I was to watch it … But even in the first films, I am far from a fan, I just think good films. Therefore, I can see your point of view.
It was very fatty sarcasm, I mean, I describe the most boring and illogical things like pluses. It seems to me even fans will agree with me that the prequels turned out … problematic. I myself love only the original trilogy. And I didn’t even see a new film, but I’m sure that they won’t be able to do it in the prequels, and this is already good.
I actually liked the film and it was above my expectations. Since I know that j.AND. For films, mediocre directors: the old track was made both, both the first and the second;The mission is impossible in the same pit – continuous explosions. There was only one old film and this is Armagedon with old man Bruce in the forefront. At least now, in addition to the series, J.AND. 2 normal films and I wish him not to constrict the next 2 episodes.
It was interesting to read your opinion, especially against the backdrop of the commentary of the respected Elfin1912.
Do not mind if I refer to your comment when creating a second video? For one of the points of the video will be about the final fight. And where without a detailed analysis of the "short-legged self-taught".
It will be interesting to continue the dispute with you … although no, not a dispute – a conversation.
Dear, what do you think from science fiction is not fierce delirium for preschoolers? I will not ask about Vakhu, but at least the Universe of the Dune Frank Herbert you … um … respect? And I’m not talking about terrible films \ TV shows, I’m talking about books.
Well, maybe so. But Abrams put his hand to him. And this is the only one in his list besides the 7th episode that looks watching.
Well, I agree that in the new trilogy (hmm … and how to call her now? New old?) there is no that lamp … but! I consider 3 episode excellent. Order to the attack aircraft, the battle of Eni and Obi-Wan … and yes, Evoki suck … Oh, this is Stopgame … Well then, Evoki suck carrots, yes ..
And about the new film, then it will like it rather to those who love the original trilogy. Abrams perfectly conveyed the atmosphere … Um … fairy tales?
The atmosphere of a fairy tale is a suitable word, I think, stellar wars, despite the cosmic networks, is closer to the lord of rings than to a stranger. And, as to the third, well, I hate her fiercely, as well as all the other prequels. There are a lot of reasons and to describe them all I need at least an hour, but one of them. The transformation of Anakin into Sith is dibal. It does not make sense at all from the point of view of the character Skywalker. Why betray the Jedi? Why not turn to them for help? Even after he helped to kill Windows, Pallpatin tells him, they say, "Well, I don’t know how to resurrect people, but we probably will manage to solve this secret together!"And what after that does Dibil do? Goes to kill your order of course, it is very obvious! After all, this will save the life of Padme. And the very reason for her death during childbirth, well, very tormented. With that level of technology, they cannot, well, I don’t know, cesarean to do? Idiocy.